Why don't jokes work to break the ice in a job interview?

Find out why jokes don't work to break the ice and what you should do instead in our must-read article for any job interviewee.

Jokes may seem like a natural way to break the ice in a job interview, but trust us, they can be a total flop! (Unless you're applying for a comedy club, of course!) Not only can cracking jokes make you seem unprofessional, but they can also distract from the real purpose of the interview: to showcase your skills and experience. So why exactly do jokes fail to break the ice in a job interview? Well, there are a few key reasons.


3 Key Reasons Not to Crack A Joke

First and foremost, jokes can be risky. It's tough to gauge someone's sense of humor, and what one person finds hilarious may be completely lost on another. If your joke falls flat, it can make the interviewer feel awkward and uncomfortable, rather than breaking the ice and creating a more relaxed atmosphere.

Furthermore, jokes can also be distracting. In an interview, the focus should be on your qualifications and experiences, not your comedic abilities. If you spend too much time cracking jokes, the interviewer may start to question your sincerity and professionalism.

Additionally, jokes can also come across as forced or inauthentic. Interviewers can spot a phony joke from a mile away, and it can make you seem insincere or lacking in genuine social skills. The key to breaking the ice in an interview is to be authentic and genuine, not to rely on canned jokes.

So, what can you do instead to break the ice in a job interview? Stay tuned for the rest of this article to find out!


The Risks of Telling Jokes in a Job Interview

Telling jokes in a job interview is a risky move because you never know how the interviewer will react. Even if you think the joke is hilarious, the interviewer may not see the humor in it. This can lead to an awkward and uncomfortable atmosphere, which is the opposite of what you want in an interview.

For example, let's say you're a marketing candidate and you make a joke about a popular brand's slogan. You think it's clever and will show off your creative thinking skills. However, the interviewer may not be familiar with the brand or simply doesn't find the joke funny. This can put a damper on the entire interview and make it difficult for you to recover.

Another risk of telling jokes in a job interview is that they can be seen as inappropriate or unprofessional. Even if you have a great sense of humor, not all jokes are appropriate for a professional setting. You may be misconstrued as not being serious in an interview where you are expected to be mature as a candidate. It's important to be mindful of your audience and the situation you're in. If you're unsure if a joke is appropriate, it's best to play it safe and skip it.


Despite the risks, some people still feel the temptation to use jokes as a way to break the ice in a job interview.

Jokes Can Distract From Your Qualifications and Experience

One of the main reasons jokes don't work to break the ice in a job interview is because they can distract from your qualifications and experience. The purpose of a job interview is for the employer to get to know you and see if you're a good fit for the position. If you spend too much time cracking jokes, the interviewer may start to question your sincerity and professionalism.

For example, let's say you're a customer service candidate and you make a joke about a common customer complaint. While you may think it's funny and shows your customer service skills, the interviewer may see it as a distraction from your actual experience and qualifications. They may wonder if you're taking the interview seriously and if you're truly qualified for the position.

Another issue with using jokes to break the ice is that they can make you seem unprepared for the interview. If you're relying on jokes to try and impress the interviewer, it may come across as if you don't have any other strengths to showcase. It's important to be prepared and have a list of your qualifications and tangible accomplishments for ready discussion during the interview.

While jokes may seem like a quick and easy way to break the ice, they can actually do more harm than good to establish a human connection with the interviewer.

Jokes Can Come Across as Forced or Inauthentic

Another reason why jokes may not be effective in breaking the ice during a job interview is because they can be perceived as a distraction from the main purpose of the interview, which is to assess the candidate's qualifications and fit for the position. Interviewers are looking for candidates who are professional and focused, and a joke may detract from this impression.

Furthermore, humor is subjective and what one person finds funny may not be the same for another person. There is a risk that the joke may fall flat or even offend the interviewer, which can seriously damage the candidate's chances of getting the job. It is important to remember that the job interview is a formal setting and it is best to err on the side of caution when it comes to making jokes.

For example, let's say you're an HR candidate and you make a joke about a common HR problem. While you may think it's relatable and shows off your HR knowledge, the interviewer may see it as a rehearsed or canned joke from a line off your mock interview - i.e. overpracticed candidate who can only "read off a script". This can make you seem insincere and like you're trying too hard to impress your interviewer.

In addition, making a joke may also give the impression that the candidate is not taking the interview or the job opportunity seriously. The interviewer may wonder if the candidate is truly interested in the position or if they are just there for the sake of it. This can raise doubts about the candidate's dedication and commitment to the job.

Overall, while it is important to be personable and show some personality during a job interview, it is crucial to strike a balance and not rely too heavily on jokes as a way to break the ice. It is better to focus on demonstrating your skills, knowledge, and fit for the position through your responses to the interviewer's questions.

Another issue with using jokes as a way to break the ice is that they can make you seem less genuine. If you're using jokes as a way to mask your nerves or lack of preparation, it can come across as inauthentic. It's important to be genuine and authentic in an interview, and to let your personality shine through naturally.

For instance, let's say you're an IT candidate and you make a joke about a common IT issue. While you may think it's funny and shows off your IT knowledge, the interviewer may see it as a rehearsed or insincere joke. This again can make you seem less genuine and like you're trying too hard to impress.

It's important to find other ways to establish a connection with the interviewer that are genuine and authentic.

Alternative Ways to Break the Ice in a Job Interview

So, if jokes aren't the best way to break the ice in a job interview, what should you do instead? There are plenty of alternative ways to establish a connection with the interviewer and create a more relaxed atmosphere.

One option is to use small talk to break the ice. This can be as simple as asking about the weather or commenting on the office decor. Small talk allows you to get to know the interviewer on a more personal level and can help ease any tension.

Another way to break the ice is to compliment the interviewer or the company. This can be as simple as saying you're excited to be interviewing with such a reputable company or that you've heard great things about the interviewer's work. Interview compliments can help establish a positive and friendly relationship with the interviewer.

You can also try using shared interests or experiences to break the ice. If you have a mutual hobby or experience, this can be a great way to establish a connection and create a more relaxed atmosphere.

While jokes may not work to break the ice in a job interview, there are plenty of other options to try.

The Importance of Being Authentic in a Job Interview

In addition to avoiding jokes, it's also important to be authentic in a job interview. This means being genuine and true to yourself, rather than trying to be someone you think the interviewer wants to hire.

💡
Remember: You found the time out of your regular 9 to 5 job to go for the interview. You don't want to put up a false front only to "lie" to your interviewer to get a job you aren't fit for - this will be an ultimate time waster for you!

Being authentic in a job interview can help you stand out from other candidates and show the interviewer who you really are. It can also help you feel more confident and comfortable, which can make a big difference in the overall success of the interview.

To be authentic in a job interview, try to be yourself and let your personality shine through. Don't try to be someone you think the interviewer wants to hire – just be yourself and let your qualifications and experience speak for themselves.

While it's important to be authentic in a job interview, it's also important to remember your audience and the situation you're in.

Being Professional in a Job Interview

While it's important to be authentic in a job interview, it's also important to remember to be professional. This means being respectful, courteous, and dressed appropriately. It also means being prepared and having a list of your qualifications and accomplishments ready to discuss.

To be professional in a job interview, be sure to arrive on time, dress appropriately, and be respectful and courteous to the interviewer. Also, be prepared and have a list of your qualifications and accomplishments ready to discuss. This will show the interviewer that you're serious about the position and that you're the right fit for the job.

💡
Basically, you want to look well-adjusted to the working environment and seem like you can fit in well.

Conclusion

While jokes may seem like a natural way to break the ice in a job interview, they can actually do more harm than good. They can be risky, distracting, and come across as forced or inauthentic. It's important to find other ways to establish a connection with the interviewer that are professional and genuine. Remember to be authentic and let your personality shine through, but also be mindful of your audience and the situation you're in. By being professional and prepared, you can make a great impression and increase your chances of landing the job.

Read next: Why We Should Hire You For This Role Instead of Someone Else?






Subscribe to Interview Question - Your Career Preparation Room

Don’t miss out on the latest issues. Sign up now to get access to the library of members-only issues.
[email protected]
Subscribe